
By SHERRY BUNTING
Special for Farmshine
HONEY BROOK, Pa. — What does a donut have to do with breeding better cows, robotic milking, knowing your numbers, and counting your blessings?
Quite a lot, according to Dutch dairyman Jan Vonk, who brought humor and practical wisdom from the Netherlands to more than 80 mostly Pennsylvania Dutch dairy farmers. They all gathered here on Friday, Nov. 13 for the Stolhaven Genetics barn meeting. The event organized by Amos Stoltzfus brought fellowship, learning, and inspiration to the stone-barn garage at the dairy farm of Josh and Stephanie Stoltzfus near Honey Brook in Chester County.
They are raising five children on this farm where Josh grew up, taking over from his parents Mark and Melody about 10 years ago and expressing gratitude for his father’s continued help. The family grows most of its own forages and milks a herd of 70 cows with more than 30 years of aAa breeding analysis behind it.
The majority of attendees were Amish and what stood out was the number of young people — attentive and clearly interested. The same could be said for the English host family as their eldest daughter was among those studying sire catalogs from event sponsors Triple Hil Sires and Masterpiece Genetics.
Vonk was the featured speaker. He and his wife operate a third-generation dairy in the Netherlands, milking 100 cows and farming 150 acres, much of it pasture on peat soils below sea level. They recently gained access to some higher ground suitable to grow corn 30 miles away.
He kicked off the discussion with a donut in hand: “You expect something sweet, but what if it were sugar-free and you hadn’t noticed the label? Someone looking more carefully might have warned you.”
Fortunately, he assured the audience, the donuts were not sugar-free. His point: What you see is what you get, but only if you know what you’re looking at.
From dairy cows and breeding decisions to feed costs, equipment investments, and the blessings of farm life, Vonk challenged attendees to look more closely, ask why, and take responsibility for their decisions.
At Vonk’s dairy, canals drain the land and serve as boundaries between long parallel fields. Temporary electric fencing divides them crosswise to give the cows fresh grass each day. The canals provide drinking water and occasional swimming for an adventurous cow.
He drew laughter explaining why the Dutch people learn how to swim because, if the dikes break, they may have to.
A year ago, he transitioned from a double-7 milking parlor to robotic milking — a change that required adjustments in feeding, cow movement, and daily management. It also required a closer look at cow mobility.
His transition to robots was unique, still milking in the parlor for the first month, allowing cows to enter the robots just for feed before milking them there.
They caught on quickly, he said: “It was a longer way for the farmer than for the cows.”
Working with a new nutritionist, he also changed his feeding program. Improved nutrition and more frequent milkings, now three to four times a day voluntarily, the herd produced 20 pounds more milk per cow per day than a year earlier, while purchased-feed costs per hundredweight declined due to the increased milk yield.
The robots also brought new responsibilities. A cow with sore feet is a problem. In a conventional parlor or tie-stall system, she would still get milked. With robots, her willingness and ability to walk determine whether she visits the robot.
Grazing remains part of the system, and is managed differently around the robots. He turns cows out around 7 a.m. for around two hours, then brings them back to the barn. They go out again in the evening for a similar period. The idea is to let them harvest fresh grass and protein, then return to rest, ruminate, and visit the robots.
Bringing them back and forth requires care. Vonk and his wife walk ahead of the cows along a concrete lane just three to four feet wide. The cows know fresh feed awaits and would gladly run back. Vonk won’t let them. The walk is single file and methodical.
“One little stone under their hoof is a lame cow, and a lame cow is a cow that doesn’t come to my robot,” he said, adding that a cow may have impressive production genetics, but if she cannot move comfortably and function in the system where she lives, those numbers may not translate into profitable longevity.
For Vonk, robotic milking has reinforced the value of breeding balanced cows, maintaining their health, and understanding how the pieces of the operation, and its equipment, work together.
What’s in your numbers?
One of Vonk’s most valuable lessons came not from new equipment, but from another farmer willing to challenge his numbers. He belongs to a group of 40 Dutch dairymen who meet twice a year to compare detailed financial information. Everyone must share all of their numbers openly within the group, and everyone must keep the information confidential outside it. The group also compares their collective results with farmers elsewhere in Europe.
He thought his purchased-feed costs were pretty good. In 2025, his milk price averaged the equivalent of $24.20 per hundredweight, while purchased-feed costs were approximately $5.70 per hundredweight of milk.
Then another farmer looked at his figures and told him he could do better. Rather than dismiss the advice, Vonk listened. His changes in feeding and milking management followed, with more milk produced from feed that wasn’t necessarily cheaper.
“Knowing why the numbers are the way they are. It’s a path to profit, and sometimes another farmer, another person, can see something in those numbers that you cannot,” he said.
It also means recognizing what cannot be controlled. A dry summer and an infestation of mice in his pastures reduced available forage, forcing more purchased feed. He knows his feed cost per hundredweight will rise, but he also knows why.
More than one way to make a farm work
Vonk and his wife have also diversified their farm. In 2008, they established a guesthouse because they love people. He had always been taught the one-way vision, that dairy farming meant milking cows and producing more milk. However, he came to believe that relying on one source of income wasn’t the best way to operate.
“I think it’s more easy to walk on two legs,” he quipped.
The guesthouse became the second leg, hosting more than 2000 guests annually and contributing about one-third of the farm’s annual profit. The couple also breeds horses, including Dutch champions.
These enterprises require their own management but illustrate his advice to “look at the resources and opportunities you have, understand your numbers, and make decisions that work for your farm.”
Seeing the blessings
Showing pictures and videos of his farm, his cows, his wife, and the operation they built together, he spoke openly about their 35 years of marriage and the fact that they have no children.
“Only God knows why,” he said, expressing gratitude for his wife and the life they share, encouraging attendees to look carefully to see their blessings every day.
A sign at the entrance to his dairy barn reads: “This farm belongs to the Lord. I am only a steward.”
Crediting former dairy farmer Jake Esh of Gordonville, Lancaster County whose barn entrance also had this sign, Vonk said it is there as something he must see daily. It reminds him of the responsibility entrusted to him and the blessings he has been given.
“What you see is what you get,” he said. Whether looking at a donut, a cow, a financial statement, or the life God has provided, there’s often more to see than what first meets the eye. Sometimes, seeing more clearly begins with being willing to look again.
Next week: The breeding decisions behind the cows. Vonk explains how he uses aAa numbers to match cows and bulls, why longevity matters more than the fanciest heifer, and how beef-on-dairy fits his replacement strategy.


